Japan is predicted to see significant recovery flows. It that the driver behind the recent moves? Looking to previous major disaster in the land of the rising sun, it is quite hard to draw any conclusions at the moment.
Guest post by FXPro
Now, as back then, Japan is still the world’s largest creditor nation, holding far more in overseas asset than overseas investors hold in Japan. It’s this that underpins the notion of substantial yen strengthening. On the surface, the potential impact of this imbalance is far greater, not only because the eventual costs are likely to exceed those of 1995, but also as that there are substantially more foreign assets now than sixteen years ago (overseas assets having doubled over the period). Furthermore, over the last twelve months those overseas assets have performed well, much better than domestic asset markets.
This argument can be offset against the fact that the Japanese corporate sector is in much better health than was the case in 1995. In the mid-‘90s, Japanese corporates were perhaps only half-way through the process of balance-sheet repair, following on from the collapse in asset prices of the late 1980s and early ‘90s. There was very little in the way of surplus funds available. The contrast with now is stark in as much that corporate Japan is running a surplus (savings over investment). Furthermore, leverage in the form of the debt-to-equity ratio has halved over the same period. So, in comparison with the mid-‘90s, whilst overseas assets are far greater (nominally and as a percentage of GDP) and have performed well, the need for firms to call on them is lower thanks to the better balance-sheet position.
Alongside this should be factored in the extent to which costs fall on the corporate and public sectors. The reaction already seen in CAT (Catastrophe) bonds suggest that markets are already adjusting to this reality, as have the Japanese bond and sovereign CDS markets (although the latter should not be over-interpreted for liquidity reasons). But the fate of the yen will lie in which effect dominates. A greater burden falling on the public sector risks pushing up public debt to levels where debt sustainability becomes an issue in the face of a diminishing domestic savings pool. This would more likely have a downward impact on the yen.
In truth, there are a lot more questions than answers for the yen at this point in time. But, for those banking on substantial appreciation, the biggest difference vs. the 1990s is the potential for the Bank of Japan to intervene. Japan’s fx reserves are over seven times the level prevailing back then and the BOJ may find international backing for intervention a little more forthcoming than was the case in September of last year. This probably would not extend to outright co-ordinated intervention to weaken the yen; rather it would be viewed far more favourably than the actions of most other Asian central banks.Get the 5 most predictable currency pairs