FOMC Minutes Show that Extended Twist was Substitute to


In the last meeting of the FOMC on June 19-20, an extension of Operation Twist was announced. There was a big debate if this is a stepping stone towards QE3, or just a substitute.

The meeting minutes give the impression that it was a substitute: only a major disaster could move the Fed towards expanding the balance sheet. This is supportive of the dollar.

Most FOMC members wanted balance sheet action: 12 out of 19. This includes both voting and non voting members. Such a wide majority, that probably includes Chairman Bernanke, sounds quite dovish.

However, balance sheet action doesn’t mean expanding it with QE3 – it doesn’t mean printing more dollars and devaluing the currency: 11 out of 12 saw more Twist as good enough at this time.

Only “a few” (translation is 2) saw a need for more bond purchases. Two other left the door open for new bond purchases in case of a deterioration – such a deterioration seems “low at present” according to the minutes.

Others took the other direction and wanted to know “how large purchases would have to be to disrupt the Treasury market” – they showed worries about the side effects.

All in all, some worries are expressed and the Fed does leave the door for more action. Nevertheless, the bar for printing more dollars remains quite high.

Next Meeting

The chances of QE3 in the July 31 / August 1 meeting is low. If expectations do rise towards this meeting, they will probably be met with another disappointment. The last QE program, QE2, ended in June 2011. Almost every FOMC meeting since then held expectations for QE3, and resulted in a disappointment.

There’s no reason to believe that this time will be different.

Get the 5 most predictable currency pairs

About Author

Yohay Elam – Founder, Writer and Editor I have been into forex trading for over 5 years, and I share the experience that I have and the knowledge that I’ve accumulated. After taking a short course about forex. Like many forex traders, I’ve earned a significant share of my knowledge the hard way. Macroeconomics, the impact of news on the ever-moving currency markets and trading psychology have always fascinated me. Before founding Forex Crunch, I’ve worked as a programmer in various hi-tech companies. I have a B. Sc. in Computer Science from Ben Gurion University. Given this background, forex software has a relatively bigger share in the posts.


  1. Market participants still don’t get it – there is NO ‪QE3‬ stimulus coming, not now, not ever! The FED printing money right before the elections is a suicide, this would be THE END for Obama and his administration (and the FED itself). I expect a huge massive sell-off in today’s US S&P500 session just like june 21st.

    • Yup, it looks like the market is beginning to accept the fact that no QE3 is coming and the dollar continues soaring across the board.

  2. Pingback: EUR/USD July 12 Struggles as Markets Disappointed over Fed Inaction | Forex Crunch

  3. Pingback: EUR/USD Closer to Critical Support – No Help Seen | Forex Crunch

  4. Pingback: US Gained Only 12K Jobs in May According to Bernanke’s Highlighted Indicatoruite | Forex Crunch

  5. Pingback: EUR/USD Outlook July 16-20 | Forex Crunch

  6. Pingback: EUR/USD July 16 Lower as Markets Cautious Ahead of Bernanke Remarks | Forex Crunch

  7. Pingback: USD/JPY Outlook July 16-20 | Forex Crunch

  8. Pingback: EUR/USD July 17 Climbing as Weak US Data Fuels Speculation of QE3 | Forex Crunch

  9. Pingback: EUR/USD July 18 Edges Lower as Markets Disappointed as Fed Balks Again | Forex Crunch

  10. Pingback: EUR/USD July 19 Limited Losses as Markets Eye Key US Data | Forex Crunch

  11. Pingback: EUR/USD Loses Ground After Weak US Releases | Forex Crunch